Quick Verdict
- LOA Roofing & Construction is the top choice for most Austin homeowners and businesses: Best overall for residential and commercial roofing in Austin, supported by a BBB A+ rating and an outstanding 5.0-star average from 1,000+ Google reviews.
- Kidd Roofing is best suited for large commercial and multi-site projects, operating across multiple cities with roots dating to 1982.
- Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal specializes in metal and sheet-metal roofing, built on a fabrication background that goes back to 1970.
- All three companies list manufacturer credentials or BBB recognition; the main differences lie in review volume, warranty terms, and how each handles follow-through and customer concerns.
For most Austin homeowners, LOA Roofing & Construction is the recommended contractor, while Kidd Roofing and Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal are strong alternatives for larger commercial projects or jobs that require metal fabrication expertise. Each firm serves Central Texas but differs in review history, accreditation details, and project focus.
Austin roofs face frequent hail, extreme heat, and sudden storms, so a contractor’s proven track record is more important than the lowest bid. NOAA data indicates a significant number of severe-storm disasters affecting Texas over recent decades, and that context underscores the importance of fast inspections, quality repairs, and reliable warranties.
The comparisons below are based on public listings and verified review platforms. No affiliate links appear in this article.
Kidd Roofing vs LOA vs Ja-Mar at a Glance
| Contractor | Operating Since | Headline Credential | Best For |
| LOA Roofing & Construction | 2018 (BBB start date) | BBB A+ accreditation | Residential and commercial roofing |
| Kidd Roofing | 1982 | GAF Master Elite | Large and multi-site commercial projects |
| Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal | 1970 | GAF Master Elite | Metal and sheet-metal roofing |
How the Review Records Compare
Online reviews reveal where each contractor consistently performs well. Review counts and averages change over time, but these snapshots show relative strength and volume across platforms.
| Platform | LOA | Kidd | Ja-Mar |
| 5.0 from 1,000+ reviews | 4.9 from ~853 reviews | 4.9 from ~685 reviews | |
| BBB rating | A+ | A+ | A- |
| Verified-review platform | BBB: 10 reviews averaging 5/5 | BBB: 21 reviews averaging 5/5 | GuildQuality: 5/5 from 10 reviews |
LOA leads in Google review volume and rating in this comparison. Ja-Mar has a long-standing BBB presence dating back to 2005, while its BBB file also reports four complaints in the past three years.
Credentials and Warranties: What Each Contractor Can Prove
Credentials matter most when verified by third parties. The following credentials were confirmed through public listings such as BBB and manufacturer directories.
- LOA Roofing & Construction: BBB Accredited Business with an A+ rating since October 29, 2018. LOA advertises a lifetime workmanship warranty and cites recognition among national Top 100 roofing contractors.
- Kidd Roofing: Listed as GAF Master Elite with a BBB A+ accreditation since 2007. Kidd also notes FORTIFIED Roof certification on some projects.
- Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal: GAF confirms Master Elite status and President’s Club recognition. BBB shows an A- rating with accreditation beginning in 2005.
Because Texas does not license roofers at the state level, signed warranties and proof of insurance are more meaningful than a license number. Always request written warranty terms and a copy of the contractor’s insurance certificate before work begins.
What Austin’s Storm Record Means for Your Roof
Severe storms account for a large share of Texas’s costly weather disasters, so priorities for Austin homeowners should include fast inspections, reliable hail-damage repairs, and contractors experienced with insurance claims. Be aware that Texas law prohibits contractors from offering to waive or rebate an insurance deductible; such promises are illegal and can result in fines and criminal penalties.
The Three Contractors in Detail
Kidd Roofing – Best for Large and Multi-site Commercial Work
Kidd Roofing operates locations in several Texas cities and some out-of-state markets, making it a logical choice for property managers and owners with multiple properties. Established in 1982, Kidd handles shingle, metal, tile, single-ply, and modified-bitumen roofing systems, and offers hail-repair and insurance-claim assistance.
Customer feedback is mostly positive, although isolated warranty follow-up complaints appear in some review channels. Strengths include decades of experience, GAF Master Elite status, and capabilities on large commercial and multi-family roofs. Drawbacks include limited published pricing and a multi-city structure that may be less appealing to homeowners seeking a local-only contractor.
Contact: Address: 1212 E Anderson Ln #200, Austin, TX 78752. Phone: (512) 671-7791. Social: Instagram profile available.
LOA Roofing & Construction – Best Overall for Residential and Commercial Roofing in Austin
LOA Roofing & Construction offers both residential and commercial roofing services from its Austin location. Services include shingle, metal, and clay tile installations, plus flat-roof systems like TPO, EPDM, and built-up roofing for commercial properties. LOA highlights same-day and drone inspections, 24/7 emergency access, free roof inspections, and a stated lifetime workmanship warranty.
LOA’s online reputation is strong, with excellent Google ratings and a BBB A+ accreditation. Manufacturer warranty coverage varies by shingle brand and product tier, so confirm the exact brand and warranty level when you request a written estimate. LOA’s combined team experience and broad service offerings make it a versatile choice for homeowners and businesses alike.
Contact: Address: 706 W Ben White Blvd Suite 200B, Austin, TX 78704. Phone: (512) 375-3654. Social: Facebook page available.
Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal – Best for Metal and Sheet-Metal Roofing
Ja-Mar specializes in metal roofing and in-house sheet-metal fabrication, making it an excellent option for standing-seam metal roofs, custom flashing, historic restorations, and detailed architectural work. Operating since 1970, Ja-Mar holds GAF Master Elite status and President’s Club recognition and generally earns strong Google ratings.
Its sheet-metal fabrication capability is especially valuable when off-the-shelf components won’t do. However, the company’s BBB rating is an A-, and its BBB file documents several complaints in recent years, so request a detailed written scope and compare it to other estimates before committing.
Contact: Address: 4101 Parkstone Heights Dr, Ste 250, Austin, TX 78746. Phone: (512) 441-8437. Social: Facebook page available.
Residential vs Commercial Scope
Project scope matters most when choosing a roofer. Kidd is tailored to large commercial and multi-family projects across multiple cities. LOA serves both residential and commercial clients from a single Austin office and has experience with flat roofing systems. Ja-Mar focuses on metal roofing and custom sheet-metal work that suits architectural and historic properties.
Which Contractor Fits Which Roof
- Homeowner replacing a shingle roof after hail: LOA Roofing & Construction—strong review volume and free inspection options.
- Property manager with multiple buildings: Kidd Roofing—for multi-site and commercial capabilities.
- Homeowner choosing standing-seam metal: Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal—for fabrication and metal expertise.
- Business owner with a flat commercial roof: LOA—for TPO, EPDM, and built-up system experience.
What to Ask Each Contractor Before Signing
Ask concise, written questions to reveal the real scope and safeguards behind each bid:
- Which brand and exact product will you install, and what manufacturer warranty tier applies? Manufacturer coverage varies by product line and affects long-term protection.
- Does the estimate itemize tear-off, underlayment, flashing, ventilation, and permit costs? Itemized bids make apples-to-apples comparisons possible.
- Will you obtain any permits required by my address? Many like-for-like shingle replacements are exempt, but larger projects often need permits in Austin.
- How is payment scheduled? Avoid paying the full cost upfront; agree on milestones and retain written payment terms.
Insist on written answers to all questions. If a contractor resists documenting warranty terms or a payment schedule, treat that as a red flag.
FAQs
Which is the best roofing contractor in Austin for a home replacement? LOA Roofing & Construction is the leading pick in this comparison, with strong Google reviews and a BBB A+ rating. Kidd and Ja-Mar also hold GAF Master Elite status—compare written quotes and warranty documentation before deciding.
Does Texas require roofers to be licensed? No. Texas has no statewide roofing license, so request proof of insurance and a signed warranty instead.
Can a roofer legally waive my insurance deductible? No. Offering to waive or rebate a deductible is illegal. Walk away from any contractor who suggests doing this.
What additional services does LOA provide? LOA lists roof repair, hail-damage inspection, storm and water-damage restoration, gutters, and general construction, along with emergency and same-day inspection options. Confirm services and response times in writing.
How does LOA’s warranty work? LOA advertises a lifetime workmanship warranty and indicates the manufacturers it uses provide 20 to 50 years of coverage depending on product and brand. Always ask for written warranty documents from both the contractor and the manufacturer.
The Bottom Line
LOA Roofing & Construction stands out as the best overall choice for most Austin homeowners and many commercial clients, thanks to its BBB A+ accreditation, strong online reputation, and advertised lifetime workmanship warranty. Kidd Roofing and Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal each serve specific needs—Kidd for multi-site commercial projects and Ja-Mar for metal and sheet-metal fabrication. Obtain written quotes from at least two contractors, confirm warranty terms in writing, and verify accreditation and insurance before signing any contract.